1、HP3PARStoreServ10000vs.NetAppFAS8000One-PagerNetApp,drive chassis. Unclear performance impact if combined with 15K FC disks. Positioning High-performance solution for diverse and unpredictable workloads. Efficient - Reduce operational costs by 50% with Get Thin or Get Virtual 50% savings guarantee.
2、Autonomic-Increase storage management efficiency by 10 times. Multi-Tenant-The new tier 1 storage for cloud computing.NetAppHPHAProductSpecificationFAS8060FASV6290StoreServ10400StoreServ10800lArchitectureUnifiedSANandNAS:scale-outandscale-up;supportsthird-partyarrayswrthFIexArrayS/WorV-SeriesSANonly
3、FC,FeOE,iSCSI):NASrequiresWindowsorIBRIXgateways;Nothird-partyarraysupportScalability8-odeSAN24-nodNAS8-nodSAN24-nodeNAS4nodes8nodesMaxhostports3611696192Maxdrives1200(240SSD)1,440(240SSD)960(256SSD)1920(512SSD)Drivetypes&autotiering100GBSSD;300GB.450GB,600GBSAS;1TB,2TB,3TB,4TBSATAFlaShPoOIS-includ
4、edwithOS100GB&200GBSSD;300GB15K,450GB&900GB10KSFFSAS:300GB&0GB15KLFFFC;1TB&2TBLFFSATAAdaDIiVeODtimiZaI3-sb-LUNDVnamiCODtimiZatiOn-full-LUN8GbFC,10GbiSCSI,FCoE;NASrequiresWindowsorIBRIXgatewaysProtocols户IaShCaChe-includedwithOS16GbFC,FCoE1iSCSI,NFS,CIFS.HTTP.FTP(1GbE&10GbE)Memory128GB192GB32GBcontrol
5、cache,64GBcontrolcache.64GBdatacache128GBdatacacheFlashCache8TBJTB-16TBN/AIADataprotectioncapabilities RAID-DP,RAID4Snapshot,SyncMirror-,MetroCIuster,DSMMP!O FIexClonee,SnapMirrors-,SnapVauIte File,volume,orLUNlevelrestore RAID1,5,6(MP),DSM/MPIO Snapshots,RemoteCopy,PeerPersistence(metrodistanceprot
6、ection)-areadd-onS/W 1.UN-IeveIrestoreBuilt-inefficiencytechnologiesSnapshot,dedupe,compression,thinprovisioning,RAID-DP,FlexVoI1DiskSanitization-allincludedwithOSRAID6(MP),thinprovisioning-includedwithOSbundleSnapshotsrequireadd-onS/WCompetitiveMappingNetAppHPFASS0603PARStoreServ10400(formerlyV400)
7、FAS62903PARStoreServ10800(formerlyV800)CompetitiveAnalysisOverview The3PARarrayfamilyhasbeenrebrandedtotheStoreServ7000forMSB&StoreServ10000forthemidtohigh-endmarket.TheysharenodesigncompatibilitywithotherstorageplatformsinHPsportfolio. 3PARisHPsgo-tostorageplatformastheyaggressivelyworktooffsetthed
8、eclineintheEVA&tapebusiness.HPsQ42013storagerevenuedecreased9%YoYeventhough3PARgrewby296%YoYin2013.Strengths Compellingperformancewiththefastest8-nodeSPC-1benchmarkontheStoreServ10800.thoughthelatencywas13.67msandthelistpricewas$1.6M. Goodthinprovisioningcapabilities,particularlyduringmigrationofext
9、ernalfatvolumesto3PARthinprovisionedvolumes. Streamlineddeploymentprovidespredefinedtemplatesofdisktype/size,RAIDtype,auto-tiering,andhostgroupsforeasystorageprovisioning.EVA-likeinterfaceprovidesEVAcustomerswithaneasiertransitionto3PARarrays. EVAMigrateorHPPeerMotionS/Woffersnon-disruptivemigration
10、pathfromEVAor3PARarraystonew3PARarrays.PeerMotionisalsosoldastooltofederate!13PARarraystogetherforLUN-IeveIdatamigrationbetweenarrays. Goodmulti-tenantQoScapabilitiesthatcontrolIOP,MBsec,&latencymin/maxWeaknesses Expensivesoftware;mostsoftware,includingtheOSandsnapshots,islicensedperdiskdriveuptoama
11、xcapbasedonthecontrollermodel-320drivecap(10400),640drivecap(10800).Oncethecapishit,thelicensesbecomeunlimited.Note:drivesaresoldinmagazinesof4diskseach. NonativeNAScapabilities.NASrequiresseparateWindowsorIBRIX(Linux)gatewayswithseparatemanagementelements. Nonativededuplication;3PARrequiresaWindows
12、2012gatewaywith32K-128Kvariable-chunkfile-baseddeduplication;worksonCIFSdataonly. Nocompression,FIashCache1orSnapVauIt. AdaptiveOptimizationauto-tieringisnotreal-timeandrequiresamulti-hourhistoricalanalysisplusamigrationwindow.AOcanberunmanuallyoronaschedule,butshouldbeexecutedduringoff-hourstoavoid
13、aperformancehit.Limitedscalability:10400:2-4controllers,10800:2-8controllers.WhileHPhasimprovedintegrationwithsomeapplicationsitstillisweak.NointegrationwithSAP,3rdpartyreferencesellforSharePoint(veryweakcomparedtoSMSP)&SingleMailboxrecovery,noSnapDriveorSnapVauIt.NewSFF10K&15KSASdisksarepackagedtof
14、itin4U40diskLFFFCStrategyandTactics HPdiscounts3PARarraysheavilytocompete,typically70-75%fortheinitialsale.Theymakeupthedifferenceduringupgrades,whichrequireadd-onsoftwarelicensesuptothecapacrossallsoftwarelicensed. 3PARsellsheavilyonitsperformanceadvantage(SPC-1benchmark&Oracletesting)basedonitswid
15、estripingofdataacrossalldisksinthesystem. HPwillpushthinprovisioningandsellitagainstNetAppdeduplicationasabettersolutionthatdoesn,timpactperformance. HPhasboth3PARGetThinGUaranteeand3PARGetVirtUalGiJarantee50%capacitysavingsguaranteeprograms.Theyclaimcustomerswillseea50%capacitysavingsduringmigratio
16、noradoublingofVMdensitywhenmovingto3PAR.Ifnot,HPwillprovideadditionaldisks,S/Wlicenses,andsupporttomakeupthedifference. HPwillselltheiravailabilityfeatures,primarilywith4+-controllerconfigurations,suchasdiskshelfavailability,symmetricactive/activecontrollers,PersistentPorts,controllerclustering&refo
17、rmationduringcontrollerfailover.WhyNetApp? Singleunifiedscale-upandscale-outarchitecture. Built-instorageefficiencyfeaturessuchasdeduplication,compression,thinprovisioning,RAID-DP,&Snapshotcopies-allincludedwiththeOS Uniquespaceefficientvaultingprovidesfastandsimplebackupandrecovery. Investmentprote
18、ctionthroughnon-disrptivedata-in-placecontrollerupgradesaswellastheabilitytoclustercontrollersofvariousage,size,andperformancewiththeabilitytovirtualizethird-partystorage. Simple,unified,cluster-widemanagementfromthelowendtothehighendreducesadministrativeburdenacrossahighlyscalableenvironment. Deepa
19、utomatedintegrationwithabroadsetofapplications. DataONTAPEdgeVSAforremoteofficeenvironments.QuestionstoAsktheCustomerCost WhatiSyourbudgetforadd-onCaPaCityandscaling?Note:HPwilldiscountheavilytogetinthedoor,butaddingcapacityrequiresadditionalcapacity-basedsoftwarelicensesthataddupquickly.Efficiency
20、HoWimportantisStorageefficiencytoyou?Note:3PARhasthinprovisioningandsnapshotsoftwarebutnodeduplicationorcompression.DeduplicationrequiresanexternalWindowsgatewaythatonlydeduplicatesCIFSdataatthefilelevel.Expandability HoWimportantisinvestmentProteCtiOntoyou?Note:3PARdoesnotofferdata-in-placecontroll
21、errefresh,clusteringbeyond4or8nodes,oramixofvariouscontrollermodels(old/new,small/large,3rdparty)inthesamecluster.-1HoWdynamicisVoUrhihDerformanCeWorkIOad?Note:3PARAuto-Tieringisnotreal-timelikeFIashCacheorFlashPools.Wouldnlyouwanttohaveautomatedtieringthathappenswhentheapplicationreallyneedsit? HoW
22、imvortantisautomationtoenhanceusability?Note:NetApphasamuchmorerobustintegrationwithkeyapplicationsincludingVMware,Oracle,Exchange,SQL,SAP1Hyper-V,SharePointplusSnapVauItbackup&recoverysoftware.AdditionalcustomautomationisavailablewithSnapCreator&WorkflowAutomation.UnifiedArchitecture HaVeVoUCOnSide
23、redNASinyourenvironment?Note:All3PARarraysrequireeitherWindowsorIBRIXgatewaysforNASfunctionality,whichrequireseparatemanagementpoints.NFSisthelogicalchoiceforVMwarebecauseVMDK,sarefiles-sowhynotputtheminafilesystemvs.aSAN?HowtoAttack 3PARisexpensivetomaintainwithitsS/Wlicensingmodel.Besuretoaskabout
24、HPbestpracticesforcontroller/capacityupgrades,whichrecommendthatdisksandshelvesbepurchasedtoequalexistingconfigurationsacrosseverycontrollerpair.AllS/Wlicensesmustalsobeupgradeduptothecap. NetApphasmuchbetterapplicationintegrationwithSnapManagertools.BesuretoaskaboutHPcustomerreferencesforapplicatio
25、n-integratedsuites. Nodata-in-placerefreshtonewerormorepowerfulcontrollers. Nomixedcontrollerclustersorthird-partyarrayvirtualization. Nonativededuplication:requiresexternalWindowsgateway. Nocompression,high-performanceRAID-DP,FIashCache1orSnapVauIt. NotaunifiedSANandNAS;3PARrequiresanexternalNASgat
26、eway. Autotieringisnotrealtimeanddatamigrationshouldberunduringoffhours.CompetitorLandminesandFUDCompetitor1.andminesandFUDU-Turn or Fact3PAR is easier to manage than NetAppNo space reservation needed for snapshotsFact:NetAppSystemsManagerisasimplemanagementenvironmentthatcanmanagepetabytesofstorage
27、asasingleinstancegreatlyreducingthenumberofadministratorsperTBacrossbothNASandSANenvironments.OurSnapManagersuiteismuchmorerobustandwehavemanycustomerinstallationstoproveit.U-Turn:HowmanycustomerreferencescanHPproducefortheirapplicationintegrationsuites?Fact:Spacereservationiscustomerconfigurableand
28、canbesettozeroifdesired.Customerstypicallyusethisfeaturetoguaranteeadequatecapacitywheresnapshotsareknowntogrowovertime.3PARvolumescanfailwhensnapspacerunsoutyettheyonlyofferalertswithnospacereservationoption.U-Turn:Howimportantarefeaturesthatkeepyoursystemsrunningwithoutinterruption?Author: Author
29、Matt Gormley Last Updated: 4 May 2014AsoftheissuedateOtthisdocument,tothebestofourknowledge,thinformationcontainedhereinisanaccurateresultofourresearchadzorefforttoobtaininformation.Thisinformationisprovided*ASIShwithnowarrantiesofanykind.NetAppoffersnowarrantythatthisInformationhasnotchangedsinceth
30、isdocumentwasissued,nordoweundertaketoupdatethisdocumentAllspecificationsaresubjecttochangewithoutnotice.NetApp,theNetApplogo.NetAppbrandsareregisteredtrademarksofNetApp.Inc.intheU.S.andothercountries.AJlotherbrandsorproductsaretrademarksorregisteredtrademarksoftheirrespectivehoMersandshouldbetreate
31、dassc,2012NetApp,Inc.AWrightsreserved.NetAppConWentiaIInformation.DistributionbmitedtoNetApppartnersunderNDAobligation.Noredisributionfightsareherebygranted.NetApp deduplication is risky and causes performance issues with primary storage.3PAR is better at block storage than NetAppFact:NetApphasbeenp
32、rovidingcustomerswithdeduplicationsince2007withExabytesofdatabeingdeduplicated.Invirtualizedenvironmentstheeffectcanbedramaticinstoragesavingsandcanevenbenefitperformancewithdedupe-awareFlashCacheandFlashPools.Itsinterestingtosee3PARjumponthededupebandwagonwithsuchaweakoffering.U-Turn:Isyourcustomer
33、interestedinbuyinglessstorageratherthanmore?Fact:IfNetAppissobadatblkstoragethenwhyisroughly50%ofourFASbusinessblock-based?U-Tum:Whatisthemarketshareof3PARmparedtoNetApp?Asoftheissuedateo(thisdocument,tothebestofourknowledge,theinformationcontainedhereinisanaccurateresultofourresearchand/orefforttoo
34、btaininformation.Thisinformationisprovided-AS-ISWithnowarrantiesofanykind.NetAppoffers-nowarrantythatthisinformationhasnotchangedsincethisdocumentwasissued,nordoweundertaketoupdatethisdocument.Allspecificationsaresubjecttochangewithoutnotice.NetApp,theNetApplogo.NetAppbrandsareregisteredtrademarksNe
35、tApp.Inc.IntheU.S.andothercountries.AHotherbrandsorProduCISaretrademarksorregisteredtrademarksoftheirrespectiveholdersandshouldbetreatedassuch.2012NetApp,Inc.Allghsreserved.AUthorAuthorMaUGomleyNetAppConWentiaIInformation.DistributionlimitedtoNetApppartnersunderNDAobligations.Noredistributionrightsareherebygranted.LastUpdated：4May2014
